Pros and Cons of School Uniforms: Experts’ Opinion

All Pros and Cons of School Uniforms: Experts' Opinion
Table of Contents

Parents and students have strong feelings on the issue of school uniforms. Actually, there are important pros and cons of school uniforms that you need to be familiar with. Backed up by solid research, I highlight the main pros and cons of wearing school uniforms in this article.

Key points

  • Some of the strongest reasons why student should wear uniform include discipline, focus on learning, school pride, and socially equalizing impact.
  • Meanwhile, the main reasons why students should not have to wear uniforms are creativity suppression, self-image problems, bullying, and potential financial burden.
  • With some online learning platforms, like Brighterly math and reading tutoring, parents and kids don’t have to worry about uniforms or dress code.

What are the pros and cons of school uniforms?

The main pros of wearing school uniforms include building a sense of community, easier morning routines, and cost savings. At the same time, major cons of school uniforms comprise loss of freedom of expression, gender issues, and students’ dislike of the concept.

So, should schools require uniforms?

Let’s dive into the pros and cons of uniforms.

What are the pros of school uniforms?

Equalizing effect

I see the elimination of socio-economic disparities as one of the most important advantages of school uniforms. Being dressed identically allows privileged and underprivileged students to look and feel the same. Once they wear the school colors, kids can forget about their differences and be truly equal, without apparent signs of wealth or lack of such.

What are the pros of school uniforms?

Better academic performance

While some research claims that there’s no evidence of the positive impact of uniforms on school grades, a study by the University of Houston demonstrates a 3-percentile-point increase in language test scores among elementary school girls following the introduction of uniforms. By removing distractions and emphasizing studying, uniforms bring academic gains, especially for younger students.

Minimized distractions

Despite the cons of uniforms, they play a key role in reducing distractions from materialistic concerns and physical possessions. Children are highly susceptible to competing with peers in terms of who has better things, such as clothes. This moves their attention from the primary goal of schooling – education – to less important things, like clothing.

Improved attendance and graduation rates

Through various channels, uniforms have the potential to positively impact school attendance and graduation rates as they highlight learning and boost school spirit. An 8-year-long study on the 8 largest public school districts in Ohio shows a 3.5% increase in attendance in 4 of the 6 schools that introduced uniforms. Moreover, schools requiring uniforms marked an 11% rise in graduation rates.

What are the cons of school uniforms?

Reduced creativity

School uniforms limit children’s and teens’ ability to self-express through fashion, hair, and accessories. This uniformity – one of the main uniform disadvantages – makes it more challenging for students to find their “tribe” or future friends. School can be stressful as it is, and taking away one of the few areas where kids can show creativity and express their nature might negatively impact their mental health.

What are the cons of school uniforms?

Dr. Amanda Gummer, Founder of The Good Toy Guide, shares her outlook on school uniforms:

“It is important to acknowledge that uniforms can sometimes limit individual expression.”

It is important to acknowledge that uniforms can sometimes limit individual expression, and as children grow, developing their identity becomes increasingly important - with clothing being a key way to express this. FA really rigid uniform policy can feel restrictive, especially for older students who are starting to explore their individuality.
Author Dr. Amanda Gummer
Dr. Amanda Gummer
Founder of The Good Toy Guide

No impact on achievement

Another negative of school uniforms is that they don’t really affect students’ grades. Looking at both the pros and cons about uniforms, a 2009 study concludes that there’s no evidence that school uniforms improve academic results. Also, a national study using data from over 6,000 school-age children shows no positive effect on attendance and behavior either.

Unaffordability

Many schools demand expensive uniforms featuring logos and specific colors from certain suppliers. This creates a financial burden for parents with limited resources who could have chosen a more budget-friendly option. Their kids might feel uncomfortable as they can’t afford the school supplier uniform, creating a sense of inequality.

Dislike by students

Some schools don’t change their uniforms for generations, and it’s not rare for children to wear the same uniform style today as their parents did 30 years ago. Kids can be disappointed to have to wear outdated colors and styles that don’t follow recent fashion trends.

School uniforms and online learning

With the rise of remote learning in recent years, some online schools require students to wear a uniform even for virtual lessons. While they justify this requirement by the assumption that clothes can visually reinforce a certain mindset, I can’t ignore the discomfort that some school uniforms can cause, especially for children sitting in front of the computer the whole day. In online education, the school uniforms cons become even more pronounced.

For example, with the Brighterly math and reading platform, students don’t need to wear a uniform or special clothes. The website offers 1:1, personalized tutoring in math, reading, and ELA for grades 1-9 that is STEM-focused and entirely US state standards-aligned.

Brighterly math and reading tutors are not only highly qualified teachers but also trained professionals who know how to understand and meet the unique personalities of diverse students. In addition to allowing children to express their individuality through clothes choice, they customize the entire learning path and all educational materials to each student’s level, grade, character, and preferences. Also, Brighterly provides grade-appropriate reading worksheets and math worksheets that target specific skills for focused practice outside tutoring sessions.

Thus, Brighterly helps your child build core and advanced math and reading skills while boosting their confidence without facing any school uniform cons.

10 reasons why students should wear uniforms

Building cohesion and equality

When children wear the same clothes, it creates a sense of similarity and equality. Students develop a more positive attitude towards each other despite different backgrounds. It basically sends the message, “We’re equal,” so kids don’t judge each other based on appearances.

Increasing safety

School uniforms help distinguish students from non-students around the school. Visually, it’s easier for teachers to keep children in safe zones, whether on school premises or during field trips.

Enhancing focus on learning

A school uniform reduces distractions. When kids wear the same clothes, they lose interest in fashion, which can be a major distraction during school hours. This helps them focus on how to get better at math and other subjects.

Promoting discipline

Are school uniforms a good idea? Yes, especially when it comes to discipline! School uniforms can encourage positive behavior. They facilitate a well-organized setting with clearly defined rules, establishing discipline among students.

Creating a sense of belonging

Some kids find school stressful, and uniforms can create an association effect and help children feel they’re not alone. This form of dress code brings unity among students as they share a common sense of identity, improving peer relationships.

Preparing for life after school

When weighing school uniforms pros and cons, we should consider that mandatory uniforms turn into a key element of school rules and regulations that prepare students for real life after school. Job interviews are a good example that if you want to look professional, you have to dress in a certain way.

Preparing for life after school

Providing easy mornings

Chaotic mornings are a leading reason for stress among students and parents. Any parent knows how hard it is to prepare a kid for school, especially when they’re not an early bird. In this case, school uniforms can be a lifesaver as they remove one thing from busy moms’ and dads’ to-do lists. When talking about school uniform pros and cons, this one is a definite pro.

Reducing expenses

Although uniforms can be expensive, sometimes you can actually save money. Most kids want to dress fashionably and can pressure their parents into buying them a new wardrobe every time a new trend sweeps through school. School uniforms reduce the financial burden of parents as kids don’t have much room for style experimentation. Buying a uniform instead of back-to-school clothes can help you save $65-$315, on average.

Developing character

When a student should wear uniform daily, they have to work harder on building their personality rather than channeling their character through clothes. Thus, kids start prioritizing personality advancement, gaining confidence and courage to show who they truly are rather than letting the clothes they wear define them.

Encouraging professionalism

Students used to wearing casual clothes to school may find it difficult to dress professionally for employment or environments that require strict dress codes. Exposing children to a school uniform early in life can teach responsibility and professionalism.

10 reasons why schools should not have uniforms

Facing objections from students

I find student resistance and even rebellion as the #1 among the top 10 reasons why students shouldn’t wear uniforms. Some children can demonstrate aggressive behavior when forced to comply with uniforms, which makes the school environment unproductive and unsafe. Students’ negative attitude is one of the largest cons of having school uniforms.

Undermining public schools

School uniforms are more prevalent in private schools rather than public schools. Pricey labeled private school uniforms look appealing to many, but they create a sense of exclusivity and widen the gap between socio-economic groups. They contribute to private school students’ feelings of superiority compared to public school students. That’s among the strongest cons about school uniforms.

Not addressing real issues

The constant debate on the pros and cons of school uniforms takes our gaze away from real issues, such as bullying, poor discipline, or poor education. Some parents may see it as a way for school administrations to whitewash the real problems. Though uniforms may have benefits, they can only do so much as mask the actual issues schools face today.

Incurring exuberant costs

According to a recent survey, the average cost of middle school uniforms is about $450. For some families, this costs more than buying regular clothes. Moreover, parents have to buy 2 separate sets of clothes – a school uniform and another one for doing an activity outside school. This poses one of the most significant disadvantages of school uniforms for families on a tight budget.

Causing peer pressure

Another of the top 6 reasons why school uniforms are bad is peer pressure which can manifest in several ways. Students in uniforms frequently feel embarrassed or judged on the street or in public transportation as they dress differently from other children wearing a more relaxed attire. Also, kids from less prestigious schools are easy to identify and made fun of by peers from more expensive schools. This is one of the most considerable cons of wearing school uniforms as children can get bullied.

Adding stress

My list of the negatives of school uniforms continues with the observation that parents have to buy at least 2-3 uniform sets so that their children have clean clothes every school day. Not only is it expensive, but it also adds to the burden of frequent laundering and ironing. This can become tiring and eat into the quality time parents could spend with their kids, helping with homework or having fun together.

Resulting in punishment

As another example of the cons of uniforms, schools with a mandatory uniforms policy punish children when they show up wearing something else. Students may face detention, parental notifications, and loss of privileges. Some schools even send children home to change, forcing them to miss out on education. In such cases, the benefits of not wearing school uniforms become too clear.

Reinforcing gender issues

Some uniforms can be straight-out sexist. Many schools require girls to wear skirts exclusively, which can be uncomfortable and bizarre in the 21st century. When parents or students object to traditionally feminine or masculine clothes, it leads to conflicts with the school administration. Minimizing gender stereotypes is one of the advantages of not wearing school uniforms.

Promoting political and commercial interests

Some parents think that the reasons why students should wear uniforms are highly political as they become a pillar of traditional values that may not resonate with their family. Furthermore, school uniforms can promote commercial interests as they are usually sold through a single supplier determined by the school administration.

Postponing adulthood

Denying students choices like what to wear may make them inadequately prepared for adulthood. When students are constantly told what to wear, how to look, and what to do, they don’t build crucial decision-making, self-expression, and independence skills. This is the final of the top 10 reasons why students should not wear uniforms.

Postponing adulthood

What percent of schools have uniforms?

As few as 18.8% of public schools in the United States, or about one-fifth, require students to wear uniforms. Due to the many cons for school uniforms, they are not prevalent.

Does one have to wear uniforms in private schools?

About 57% of private schools in the US impose school uniforms, which is significantly more than the percentage at public schools. The more ample financial opportunities of families whose children attend private schools allow them to minimize some of the cons of school uniforms and maximize the pros.

Conclusion

The pros and cons of school uniforms are an endless matter of disagreement among educators, parents, and students. This debate has also attracted attention from numerous scholars, providing evidence in both directions. The pros of wearing school uniforms include better safety, more cohesion, and less time and money spent on clothes. Meanwhile, uniform disadvantages cover depressed self-identity, bullying, and additional stress.

Whatever your opinion on school uniforms, your child’s education comes first. If you feel like your kid could use an extra push in math or reading stress-free, Brighterly is here to help you – just book free lesson  and watch it unravel.

Want your kid to excel in math and reading?

Kid’s grade

  • Grade 1
  • Grade 2
  • Grade 3
  • Grade 4
  • Grade 5
  • Grade 6
  • Grade 7
  • Grade 8
Image full form