• Math tutors
• /
• Blog
• /
• ABCmouse vs Starfall vs Brighterly: Pros, Cons, and Key Differences

ABCmouse vs Starfall vs Brighterly: Pros, Cons, and Key Differences

On the search for the best online education platforms to support your child’s learning? Here, I’m comparing and contrasting ABCmouse vs Starfall vs Brighterly to help you select the most fitting option for your kid’s needs and interests. As an experienced reading teacher, I’m looking at the main features, pricing, and reviews of the three websites to highlight their pros, cons, and differences.

Key points

• ABCmouse is a gamified learning platform that covers a wide range of subjects.
• Starfall is a mobile app using gamification to help learn reading and math.
• Brighterly offers high-quality, 1:1, individualized tutoring in ELA and math for academic excellence.

ABCmouse vs Starfall vs Brighterly: Side-by-side comparison

The main difference between ABCmouse vs. Starfall vs. Brighterly is that the first two platforms provide digital resources to supplement studying through games, books, and puzzles, while the third one offers 1:1, personalized, real-time online tutoring. ABCmouse and Starfall can be used both at school and at home, but Brighterly is designed for use at home.

Also, ABCmouse and Starfall target generally younger children, from pre-kindergarten to 2nd grade and 5th grade, respectively, whereas Brighterly works with slightly older children, from 1st to 9th grade.

Meanwhile, an important similarity between the three learning resources is that they offer personalization. They work for students attending public schools and those enjoying the benefits of homeschooling or roadschooling.

	ABCmouse	Starfall	Brighterly
Best for	Gamified learning through independent activities	Multisensory learning focused on exploration, play & wonderment	1:1, real-time, individualized tutoring
Grades	PreK-2	PreK-5	1-9
Academic subjects	Reading Math Science Social studies Art & colors Music	ELA Math	Reading ELA Math
Most noticeable features	Game-based learning 850+ lessons (prerecorded videos) Books Songs Puzzles Printables Rewards	Learning apps 700+ learning activities Practice books Instructional kits Games Puzzles Teaching tools	Award-winning curriculum Common Core compliance STEM focus Professional & fun tutors Affordable pricing Free supplementary materials
Personalized learning	Limited	Limited	✅ Fully personalized learning path, instruction & materials
Common Core alignment	❌	✅	✅
Progress tracking	✅ ABCmouse Progress Tracker	✅ Progress monitoring tools	✅ Ongoing feedback Monthly progress reports
Suitability for children with learning disabilities	Some activities might be suitable for kids with special needs & learning challenges	✅ Suitable for children with special needs & learning disabilities	✅ Fully customized to the unique needs of all learners
Trustpilot score	1.3	3.7	4.4

 

Starfall vs ABC Mouse vs Brighterly cost: Comparing plans

	Pricing	Freebies
How much does ABCmouse cost?	$14.99/month	30-day free trial
How much does Starfall cost?	$35/year for membership $5.99/month for the main app Additional costs for other materials	Free apps
How much does Brighterly cost?	Starting from $17.30/lesson with a yearly subscription and 3 classes/week	First free lesson Free math & reading tests Free math & reading worksheets

 

All three e-learning platforms – ABCmouse and Starfall and Brighterly – provide cost-efficient options. ABCmouse and Starfall cost less than Brighterly, but they rely on prerecorded videos and digital books and games, with zero interaction with human teachers. Meanwhile, Brighterly is focused on 1:1 tutoring with professional human teachers.

ABC Mouse vs Starfall vs Brighterly: Which is the top choice for your kid?

Brighterly is a strong choice alongside ABCmouse and Starfall, offering a high degree of personalization, full Common Core alignment, top-notch tutors, affordable pricing, and a library of free learning materials.

ABCmouse and Starfall can provide value to young kids and parents who’re looking for game based learning options. However, they are generally better for supplemental practice through games, puzzles, music, and other fun activities, to apply the skills gained at school. They cannot be used as a standalone instruction.

How does Brighterly work?

The Brighterly math and reading platform specializes in 1:1 online tutoring in math, reading, and ELA for grades 1-9. The main difference between ABCmouse or Starfall and Brighterly is that the latter delivers personalized instruction and practice to students below, at, and above grade level with diverse learning requirements.

What is Brighterly best at?

💡More than 200,000 families have selected Brighterly over ABCmouse, Starfall, and other platforms for customized instruction, noticeable improvements in school performance, knowledgeable and caring tutors, and great customer service — all praised in parent reviews on Trustpilot.

Brighterly key features

• Unique learning path accommodating US requirements
• Highly educated, kind tutors
• High value for money

Unique learning path accommodating US requirements

The first outstanding feature of Brighterly that catches my eye when comparing ABCmouse vs Starfall vs Brighterly is the curriculum that combines the best of both worlds. Before getting started, a student undergoes a detailed assessment to pinpoint their academic strengths, weaknesses, knowledge gaps, and personal interests. Then Brighterly math and reading tutors work hand-in-hand with the parents to prepare the learning path. This high level of personalization boosts engagement, along with curiosity for stronger skill improvements.

The Brighterly reading program provides a systematic, yet exciting approach that enhances fluency. It tackles core literary skills, vocabulary growth, text analysis, and critical thinking to improve not only speed but also reading comprehension.

In addition, Brighterly offers a math program that covers both basic and advanced concepts, including algebra and geometry. Tutoring is customized in accordance with the requirements of the grade level, as well as the student’s unique powers and struggles.

Highly educated, kind tutors

Brighterly math and reading tutors have a Bachelor’s degree or more and over 5 years of teaching experience. Importantly, they have undergone pedagogy training to develop the expertise to build an approach tailored to each student’s learning style and demands as well as the family’s preferences and goals. On top of professionalism, Brighterly tutors exhibit an unmatched love for teaching and enthusiasm to help students improve their school performance.

The combined effect of tutors’ expertise and devotion is engaging lessons, motivated children, and sizable knowledge gains. Don’t just take my word for granted – have a look at what parents write on Trustpilot.

High value for money

When looking at ABCmouse vs Starfall vs Brighterly, I can clearly see the value that the last one provides to both students and parents. Brighterly starts with a free lesson that allows you and your child to make sure that it is the right fit for your needs.

The Brighterly math and reading worksheets for kids are fully free and can easily be printed from the comfort of your home. Kids can use them to implement the knowledge they obtain during tutoring sessions in a practical and fun way to consolidate skills.

Another invaluable benefit is the Brighterly free math and reading tests available on the website. They are an indispensable part of the learning process as they help families track progress. In this way, they can know that tutoring is really working and providing the expected outcomes. 

In sum, Brighterly stands out for its focus on personalized learning, expert tutors, and delivering strong results for families.

What is the Brighterly cost?

• 1-month membership: From $20.70/lesson for 3 lessons/week
• 3-month membership: From $20.20/lesson for 3 lessons/week
• 6-month membership: From $19.40/lesson for 3 lessons/week
• 12-month membership: From $17.30/lesson for 3 lessons/week

The Brighterly cost is affordable, starting at only $17.30/class with an annual subscription that entails 3 classes/week, which is less than the average tutoring rates per hour across the United States.

Brighterly pros and cons

Brighterly pros

✅ Fully customized learning

✅ Face-to-face interaction with human teachers

✅ Meeting and exceeding the standards of the US educational system

✅ Flexible schedule

✅ Below-average tutoring price

✅ Free materials to test knowledge and practice skills

Brighterly cons

❌ 1:1 tutoring requires some time commitment

What is ABCmouse best at?

• Gamified approach to learning (suitable for young children)
• Diverse options, including prerecorded videos, games, books, songs, and puzzles
• Supplemental homeschool curriculum

How does ABCmouse work?

ABCmouse works as an early childhood education platform that implements gamification to boost engagement and develop early learning skills. The website provides instruction via prerecorded learning videos as well as practice through games, books, puzzles, and other fun activities.

My review of ABCmouse and Starfall and Brighterly reveals that the first one offers wider subject coverage that starts with reading but also expands into math, science, social studies, art, and music. The ABCmouse reading program includes phonemic awareness, letter recognition, parts of speech, and other items. It can be used by teachers in a class group and by parents at home. On the flip side, like Starfall and unlike Brighterly, there is no real-time interaction with teachers.

The ABCmouse Progress Tracker allows parents to measure daily engagement by academic subject and level. The tool helps track how much work a child does but not the achieved progress with regards to actual knowledge and skills.

Another feature children enjoy is the ABCmouse rewards in the form of tickets. Kids earn tickets when completing activities that they can use to customize their avatar or purchase items for their virtual classroom. These gamification elements instigate participation, but I think young children might also get distracted by them.

A few other features worth mentioning are the online interactive zoo, aquarium, and farm.

What ages is ABCmouse for?

ABC mouse is designed for small kids, 2-8 years of age. In terms of grades, this translates into pre-kindergarten to 2nd grade. This is a more limited grade level coverage than what Starfall and Brighterly offer.

What is the ABCmouse cost?

The standard ABCmouse pricing is $14.99/month. There is also an annual subscription which costs $45/year. Moreover, ABCmouse offers a 30-day free trial. The company website says that you can cancel your plan at any point.

💡As you can see, ABCmouse is very affordable, but it lacks personalized tutoring and individualized feedback, which Brighterly provides. Self-paced platforms, such as ABCmouse, usually lead to slower and less visible academic boosts than 1:1 support.

ABCmouse pros and cons

ABCmouse pros

✅ Multiple options for practice

✅ Modern approach based on technology

✅ Cheap cost

ABCmouse cons

❌ Risk of spending too many hours per day in front of the screen

❌ Total lack of interaction with teachers

❌ Stronger focus on fun than learning

What is Starfall best at?

• Easily accessible mobile app for reading and math learning
• Various fun-based activities, including games, books, and songs
• Platform built with students with disabilities (such as dyslexia) in mind

How does Starfall work?

Starfall operates as a collection of online educational resources for young learners. This is an early childhood learning platform based on untimed, multisensory games that use interactivity and fun to teach basic school concepts.

Similar to ABC mouse and unlike Brighterly, Starfall relies heavily on gamification and independent activities without offering any feedback from teachers. The program can be used inside the classroom and at home. In addition to access to the main Starfall mobile app, parents can also get supplementary apps, different instructional kits, practice books, reading books, games, puzzles, and other resources.

Like Brighterly and unlike ABCmouse, the Starfall curriculum is coordinated with the Common Core. The Starfall reading program, in particular, covers phonics, common sight words, and audiovisual activities to make it both effective and appealing for little kids who are now learning how to read.

So, if you’re asking yourself “Is Starfall better than ABCmouse and Brighterly?”, the answer is that it’s slightly better than ABCmouse for being Common Core-coordinated but it’s less good than Brighterly because it doesn’t offer 1:1 learning with a teacher.

What is the Starfall cost?

Starfall home membership costs $35/year for access to 700+ activities, including math and reading content, songs, and rhymes. Alternatively, you can get the app through the Apple App Store or the Google Play Store for $5.99/month. There is no free trial.

The Starfall Store offers additional learning materials, each of which has to be paid for separately.

Extra learning materials cost

• Individual apps: From free to $4.99
• Instructional kits: Up to $19.95/set
• Practice books: Up to $9.95/set

💡Starfall provides a mobile app to work on math and reading skills via fun, interactive resources. However, there is no instruction or support from a real teacher, which limits the learning potential.

So, if you’re wondering “Is Starfall worth the money?”, I’d say “Yes!” because the cost is affordable. However, the platform generally works well for students who are at grade level and need some extra practice. It’s a poor fit for those behind or those who’d like to truly excel.

Pros and cons of Starfall

Starfall pros

✅ Technology-driven platform with easy access

✅ Diverse educational materials

✅ Cost-effective pricing

Starfall cons

❌ No access to teachers

❌ Limited personalization

❌ Less subject coverage than ABCmouse

ABCmouse vs Starfall vs Brighterly Reddit & Trustpilot reviews

• ABCmouse reviews
• Starfall reviews
• Brighterly reviews

ABCmouse reviews by parents

ABCmouse reviews on reliable third-party websites, like Reddit and Trustpilot, reveal both positive and negative experiences.

ABCmouse reviews: What customers like

• Effective learning
• Helps build love for learning at a young age

 “It’s been a great learning tool.” – Reddit review

“I think it has really been good to help develop a love of learning since the games are fun and is something we can do together.” – Reddit review

ABCmouse reviews: What users dislike

• Lack of feedback to support learning
• Boring and disengaging

“I dislike ABC Mouse because it doesn’t provide corrective feedback that allows kids to see and understand their mistakes.” – Reddit review

“It’s honestly quite disappointing. It’s a bit boring for her and none of the games are particularly engaging.” – Reddit review

Starfall reviews by parents

Similar to ABC mouse, Starfall gets both positive and negative reviews from parents.

Starfall reviews: What customers like

• Good learning resource for small kids
• Entertaining activities to support early childhood education

“So far it’s taught three of my kids their letters, the names of shapes (2- and 3-D) and some rather good vocabulary from the books.” – Trustpilot review

“Starfall is another great app for early literacy and math skills with interactive activities that keep learning fun.” – Reddit review

What are the disadvantages of Starfall according to parents?

• Overly simplistic content, even for kindergarten
• Not worth a paid membership

“If he’s already in kindergarten he may find it boring or too babyish.” – Reddit review

“It’s not convincing enough to pay for.” – Reddit review

Brighterly reviews by parents

Brighterly reviews by parents are overwhelmingly positive, with an average Trustpilot rating as high as 4.4.

Brighterly reviews: What customers love

• Personalized, entertaining, effective lessons
• Excellent tutors
• Fast results

“The session is fun, engaging, it makes the learning easier to follow when it is customized to the level of the kids.” – Trustpilot review

“Very competent, caring, smart tutors.” – Trustpilot review

“This is our second week and my daughter is excited to learn every week! I can see improvement so far!!” – Trustpilot review

Starfall vs ABC mouse vs Brighterly reviews on third-party websites show that Brighterly’s personalized, face-to-face approach really gives superior outcomes.

Main ABCmouse vs Starfall vs Brighterly differences

The key difference between ABCmouse and Starfall, on one hand, and Brighterly, on the other, is that the former are online platforms for independent study, while Brighterly offers 1:1, personalized help. ABCmouse and Starfall are cheaper, but they lack face-to-face instruction and practice, which provide significantly better educational outcomes.

ABCmouse vs Starfall vs Brighterly: What is best for your child?

Starfall vs ABC mouse vs Brighterly reviews show that all three platforms can bring value to students and their families. But they serve different purposes through various features.

• If you’re looking for a gamified approach to kindergarten and elementary school subjects, ABCmouse might be worth it.
• If you want to focus on early reading fluency with a math component and don’t demand real teachers, Starfall might be a good option.
• If you want to help your child excel at reading and math and develop a lifelong passion for studying, then Brighterly is your top choice.

Here’s what Brighterly provides to students:

✅ End-to-end customized learning plan in reading and math

✅ Top of the top tutors who make studying fun and effective

✅ Affordable pricing enhanced by unlimited access to free educational resources

So, what’s holding you back from unleashing your kid’s  academic  potential?  Book free reading lesson to understand the difference between non-human educational platforms and 1:1 personalized tutoring.

Comparisons of other top-rated learning websites

After this ABCmouse vs Starfall vs Brighterly comparison, you might be interested in learning more about other digital educational platforms, too. Here are some more comparison articles to expand your options:

• IXL vs iReady vs Brighterly: Which One Is Better for 2025?
• Kumon vs Huntington vs Brighterly: Which One Is Better? (2025)
• IXL vs Khan Academy vs Brighterly: Which one is better? (2025)