• Math tutors
• /
• Blog
• /
• Hooked on Phonics vs ABC mouse vs Brighterly: Which Platform Is the Best for Your Child?

Hooked on Phonics vs ABC mouse vs Brighterly: Which Platform Is the Best for Your Child?

Looking for an effective way to help your young child learn to read better? Hooked on Phonics vs ABC mouse vs Brighterly all offer good options, albeit through a different methodology and various features. As an ELA teacher with years of experience, I’ve compared the three platforms, including their learning philosophy, functionalities, pricing, and parents’ reviews, to highlight the pros and cons of each, with the ultimate objective of assisting you in this important choice for your kid’s education.

Key points

• Hooked on Phonics combines a mobile app and printed workbooks for learning how to read independently.
• ABCmouse uses gamification to teach young children basic reading skills as well as other subjects.
• Brighterly offers individualized, online tutoring in reading and ELA (as well as math) that is done on a 1:1 basis and in real time.

Hooked on Phonics vs ABC mouse vs Brighterly: Side-by-side comparison

The main difference between ABC mouse vs Hooked on Phonics vs Brighterly is that the first two are reading apps that help young kids practice and gain skills through video lessons and games, while Brighterly offers a fully personalized reading program based on 1:1, synchronous, online tutoring.

	Hooked on Phonics	ABCmouse	Brighterly
Best for	Step-by-step phonics-based literacy learning	Gamified reading learning curriculum for young children	1:1, real-time reading tutoring for students at all levels
School subjects	Reading Spelling Math	Reading Math Science Social studies Art Music	Reading ELA Math
Grades	PreK-2	PreK-2	1-9
Reading skills	Phonics Phonemic awareness Fluency Vocabulary Comprehension Spelling	Phonics Letter recognition Parts of speech	Comprehensive reading fluency Phonics & word recognition Vocabulary & language development Reading comprehension Main ideas Story structure Key details
Most valuable features	Step-by-step guide to learning Gamified approach Animated videos Games eBooks Monthly workbooks Reward stickers & certificates Print materials Progress tracking	Game-based learning Prerecorded video lessons Books Songs Puzzles Printable materials Rewards Progress tracking	Fully customized learning path & materials Top-rated reading tutors Common Core-aligned program Library of free learning materials Affordable pricing Ongoing feedback & monthly progress reports
Personalization	Limited	Limited	✅
Common Core alignment	✅	❌	✅
Fit for students with learning challenges	✅	Some suitable activities	✅
Trustpilot rating	3.8	1.3	4.5

 

Hooked on Phonics vs ABC mouse vs Brighterly cost: Pricing comparison

	Pricing	Freebies
Hooked on Phonics cost	$329.99/year Additional pricing for extra materials	Free printables Free parent resources
ABCmouse cost	From $14.99/month	Free 30-day trial
Brighterly cost	From $17.30/class (with annual subscription for 3 lessons/week)	Free first reading lesson Free printable reading worksheets Free reading tests Free practical tips & advice (Brighterly blog)

 

My impression is that all three reading websites for kids provide cost-effective options for the parents of young learners. It is true that Hooked on Phonics and ABCmouse cost less per month, but you should remember that the apps rely on prerecorded lessons, games, and other materials and do not offer any learning from real human teachers. Meanwhile, Brighterly delivers face-to-face tutoring by professional reading and ELA teachers.

At such a young age, it’s important for kids to interact with teachers in real time. Tutors are able to catch any issues right away and come up with an appropriate solution. Moreover, 1:1 tutoring allows students to ask all the questions they have.

What is better: Hooked on Phonics vs ABC mouse vs Brighterly?

The best program among the three competitors depends on your family’s exact expectations and your child’s unique needs. Between ABC mouse or Hooked on Phonics or Brighterly, the latter is really worth my attention with the completely personalized reading curriculum that is simultaneously compliant with the Common Core State Standards. Furthermore, lessons are delivered on a 1:1 basis by real teachers with impressive experiences.

Hooked on Phonics and ABCmouse, on the other hand, are very similar as mobile apps that depend on animated video lessons, songs, and games to teach reading to small kids. While these activities can help at-level students further develop their phonics knowledge and reading skills, they cannot be used to teach reading fluency from scratch. Success with Hooked on Phonics and ABCmouse is largely driven by the parents’ engagement in the learning process.

What is Brighterly reading program?

The Brighterly math and reading platform supplies 1:1 reading (and math) tutoring to students in grades 1-9 (elementary, middle, and early high school). Learning paths and materials are individualized to each child’s skills and gaps after a thorough knowledge assessment. Sessions are flexible to match your kid’s schedule. 

Why over 200,000 US parents have chosen Brighterly

The main reasons why so many families select Brighterly over other reading programs – as testified in reviews on Trustpilot – are:

💡Smart, knowledgeable, kind-hearted tutors

💡Engaging lessons

💡Personalized approach for effectiveness with diverse learning styles

💡Easy processes for parents

Brighterly reading program features

• Thoroughly personalized reading program
• Excellent reading tutors
• Affordable tutoring rates & free resources

Thoroughly personalized reading program

When comparing ABCmouse vs Hooked on Phonics vs Brighterly, the first thing that caught my eye was the unmatched degree of teaching style and reading content personalization that Brighterly offers compared to the other two alternatives. After evaluating the strengths and weaknesses of each child, the assigned tutor develops a comprehensive plan to address the exact learning gaps. Then, they collaborate with parents to choose the topics that will appeal the most to the child and will have the highest educational impact.

While individualization is at the core of the Brighterly reading program, it’s completely coordinated with the Common Core to ensure your child’s knowledge corresponds to – or exceeds – grade levels nationally. This makes the platform a good choice both for students attending public schools and homeschooling families.

Besides reading, Brighterly also has a full-fledged math program that goes well beyond the basics of counting, addition, subtraction, and numbers. It is based on the same concept of 1:1 tutoring as the reading program. I consider this an important benefit as, if needed, your child can simultaneously develop their knowledge in two core academic subjects.

Excellent reading tutors

When comparing Hooked on Phonics vs ABC mouse vs Brighterly, the second most outstanding feature of the Brighterly reading program is the top-notch teachers. First of all, unlike the other two apps, Brighterly provides students with access to real-time tutors who can select the best methodology, provide instant feedback, and respond to any questions immediately.

Second, Brighterly only works with reading tutors with a Bachelor’s degree or higher and 5+ years of experience in teaching ELA. This guarantees their qualifications and ability to follow the Common Core principles.

Third, the company carefully vets candidates to select only compassionate, kind tutors who are pleasant to work with. The positive impact on engagement and learning outcomes is evident in parents’ reviews on Trustpilot.

Affordable tutoring rates & free resources

While private tutoring can be prohibitively expensive for many families, Brighterly charges affordable fees, which I cover in detail below. To provide additional value for parents, the platform gives access to high-quality free educational resources where children can practice and test phonemic awareness and other reading skills.

The first free resource is reading worksheets for kids in grades 1-9, which can be easily printed so that your child spends less time in front of the screen. Access doesn’t require a Brighterly subscription, but for students who get reading tutoring via the platform, these worksheets provide invaluable extra practice to strengthen knowledge.

💡You can take a look at a question from 2nd grade phonics worksheets to see how the practice combines theoretical knowledge with real-life examples.

The second free asset is grade-appropriate reading tests, which also don’t require a Brighterly account. You can assign your child a test before enrolling them in tutoring to identify the areas where they need help. After they start lessons, you can use the assessments to evaluate their progress over time.

With Brighterly, free online tests are not the only way to keep track of your kid’s progress. Tutors share feedback continuously and send monthly progress reports.

How much does the Brighterly reading program cost?

• 1-month reading program subscription: From $20.70/lesson
• 3-month reading program subscription: From $20.20/lesson
• 6-month reading program subscription: From $19.40/lesson
• 12-month reading program subscription: From $17.30/lesson

Brighterly comes with affordable pricing that starts at only $17.30 with a yearly plan. This is about half the average reading tutor cost of $32.50 in the United States. Moreover, the reading tutoring program starts with an absolutely free first class so that you and your child can get a flavor of the experience and decide if it’s the right choice for your family.

What does Hooked on Phonics stand for?

• App-based framework combining videos, songs, and games
• Monthly workbooks for hands-on writing practice
• Skill-specific storybooks

How does Hooked on Phonics work?

The Hooked on Phonics reading program operates through a combination of a mobile learning app and printed workbooks. In this way, the platform brings together a modern, game-based approach with a more traditional, hands-on methodology. It promises to teach young children to read with only 15 minutes a day.

Hooked on Phonics uses a research-based method that focuses on phonics instruction as an effective way to learn to read. The mobile app provides animated videos, games, and songs for learning and practicing various reading elements. It also provides custom-made storybooks that emphasize the skills required by the child.

Meanwhile, Hooked on Phonics sends monthly printed workbooks. That’s where children can practice and develop early writing skills.

In terms of skills, the program teaches the five pillars of reading including:

• Phonemic awareness
• Phonics
• Vocabulary
• Fluency
• Reading comprehension

One thing that Hooked on Phonics is clearly missing is instruction and practice with real teachers. Based on my experience, while gamified exercises can help consolidate skills, young children demand 1:1 interaction with teachers to understand the basics and form a solid basis for further skill development. In case you opt for this program, you’d need to be available to help your kid along.

How much does Hooked on Phonics cost?

Access to the Hooked on Phonics App Ultimate Pack costs $329.99/year, so the Hooked on Phonics monthly cost amounts to $27.50. The pack includes a subscription to the mobile app and practice sets for 3 subjects.

While there is no free trial, first-month access costs $1.00, which is basically free. Additional materials and bundles can be purchased from the online store for prices reaching up to $304.99.

So, based on features and pricing, is Hooked on Phonics worth it?

I’d say that Hooked on Phonics can be worth it in case your child is on-grade level and needs some extra exercise in reading and writing to confirm already existing skills. The reason is that the price is rather affordable. However, this program is not the right option for kids who are seriously behind or who strive to become above-average readers.

👉The Hooked on Phonics app uses gamification to help little children learn how to read, which might be fun for some kids but boring and ineffective for others. The absence of in-person instruction and guidance restricts the educational potential of the program.

What is ABC mouse best at?

• Game-based learning program
• 850+ lessons in diverse subjects, organized in 10 levels
• Learning videos, books, games, puzzles, and other activities

How does ABCmouse work?

Like Hooked on Phonics and unlike Brighterly, ABCmouse is a mobile learning app designed for young children, PreK-2. The program’s philosophy rests on game-based learning through animated videos and exciting activities, resembling adventure series. Kids even have their own customizable avatar and a virtual classroom to take care of.

ABC mouse aims to position itself as a popular homeschooling resource, but it can also be used at school or at home after school. Homeschooling parents should note that the reading program is not a full-size curriculum; it’s rather a supplement.

When choosing Hooked on Phonics or ABC mouse or Brighterly, keep in mind that ABCmouse covers more academic subjects but less deeply. Specifically, the ABCmouse reading program teaches:

• Phonics
• Letter recognition
• Parts of speech

So, if you’re wondering “Does ABCmouse help with phonics?”, the answer is Yes.

Once again, similar to Hooked on Phonics, I feel that ABCmouse relies too heavily on technology and gamification while forgetting all about the need for interaction with teachers when it comes to such young kids, as PreK-2.

Does ABCmouse cost money?

Yes, ABCmouse is a paid app. The ABC mouse monthly fee is $14.99. Alternatively, the annual ABCmouse price is $45.00/year. Parents can access a 30-day free trial before getting a paid subscription.

So, considering features and cost, is ABCmouse worth it?

I think ABCmouse can serve as a useful supplemental material to a more structured reading curriculum, like this offered by Brighterly, for example. The heavy focus on animations and fun activities makes it an independent main resource for learning.

👉Despite the low cost, ABCmouse lacks a human component, strong personalization, and corrective feedback, which makes it suboptimal for young students who are not only studying how to read but also still building basic learning skills. While it adds some value, ABCmouse needs to be used with a more solid reading program for optimal results.

Hooked on Phonics vs ABC mouse vs Brighterly Reddit & Trustpilot reviews

• Hooked on Phonics reviews
• ABCmouse reviews
• Brighterly reviews

Hooked on Phonics reviews

Hooked on Phonics reviews on Reddit and Trustpilot (average rating of 3.8) are a mix of praises and complaints.

Hooked on Phonics reviews: Pros according to parents

• Efficient teaching of sight words
• Actual positive results

“Hooked on Phonics actually teaches a lot of sight words.” – Reddit review

“I see a change in their reading.” – Trustpilot review

Hooked on Phonics reviews: Cons according to parents

• Not a full curriculum
• Repetitive patterns of no interest to small kids

“We also love the Homer App, Hooked on Phonics, Teach Your Monster to Read, and PBS Kids. That being said, these apps are just for fun, he gets a little of time daily to play his games, these do not make up our core curriculum.” – Reddit review

“It’s not very interactive. It keeps repeating the same pattern.” – Trustpilot review

ABCmouse reviews

Digging into ABC mouse reading reviews, I saw both positive and negative experiences. Comparing Hooked on Phonics vs ABC mouse review average on Trustpilot, the latter scores only 1.3. Let’s take a more detailed look at ABC mouse reviews by parents.

ABCmouse reviews: Pros according to parents

• Excellent practice
• Engaging gamification

“ABCMouse has been wonderful both for activities and helping us as parents get an idea of what to work on.” – Answer in Hooked on Phonics vs ABC mouse Reddit thread.

“ABC Mouse was great for our family… Your character goes about a school learning different subjects.” – Reddit review

ABCmouse reviews: Cons according to parents

• Lack of proper logical structure
• Failure to grab children’s attention

“ABC Mouse was not a hit. Their toddler didntly follow any real logical  path.”  –  Reddit review

“He played some of the games for a couple days then lost interest.” – Trustpilot review

Brighterly reviews

Compared to Hooked on Phonics and ABCmouse, Brighterly reading reviews are exceptionally glowing, with an average Trustpilot score of 4.5.

Brighterly reviews: Parents’ favorites

• Superior customization
• Engaging classes
• Perfect fit for students with learning challenges

“Thoughtfully tailored to each child’s learning style.” – Trustpilot review

“The teacher (Lee) makes learning fun and engaging.” – Trustpilot review

“She has a gift of recognizing my son’s Autistic triggers and how to address them without stopping the lesson.” – Trustpilot review

What’s the key difference between Hooked on Phonics vs ABC mouse vs Brighterly?

The key difference between Hooked on Phonics, ABC mouse and Brighterly is that the former two are mobile apps using gamification to teach reading, while the latter is a private tutoring platform. Brighterly provides face-to-face instruction, individualized practice, and continuous personalized feedback, which is completely absent from the other two.

In terms of cost, Hooked on Phonics and especially ABCmouse are cheaper because they rely on prerecorded videos and games, and zero time with actual teachers. Brighterly, meanwhile, charges fees below the national average, while offering customized lessons by top-of-the-top teachers.

ABC mouse or Hooked on Phonics or Brighterly: What’s the best?

My comparison of Hooked on Phonics vs ABC mouse vs Brighterly reveals that all three reading programs can help little learners with reading skills. However, they work very differently and meet various educational needs. The bottom line is:

• If you’re on the search for a consolidated approach that combines online learning with hands-on workbooks (but still misses real teacher instruction), Hooked on Phonics sounds like the right choice.
• If you’re looking for a gamified method that goes beyond reading, ABCmouse could work out for you.
• If you want to give your child what it takes to become a reading wizard, then you should check out Brighterly.

With Brighterly, children and parents benefit from:

✅ Personalized reading program for fluency and comprehension

✅ The best possible reading tutors augmenting professional experience with people skills

✅ Affordable cost along with free resources

Ready to put your child on the path to academic success? Book free reading lesson to see the difference between 1:1 tutoring and mobile apps for yourself.

Comparison of other reading platforms

Whether you found what you’re looking for or not in this review of the similarities and differences between Hooked on Phonics vs ABC mouse vs Brighterly, it’s a good idea to explore more options for your child. The following articles provide readily available comparisons of more reading resources for young kids:

• Reading Eggs vs ABC mouse: What You Need to Know Before Choosing
• Best Brains vs Kumon vs Brighterly: Which Is Better in 2025
• Best Reading Program for Kids: Top 7 Choices for 2025